A garage sale is about selling a lot of things in a day, not getting every last coin. Spend your time on the few items worth real money, and use simple, round prices for the rest.
Sort first
Put items in three piles: worth checking (electronics, tools, brand names, collectibles), ordinary items and giveaways. Spend your pricing time on the first pile.
Check the valuable pile
Use the photo check on this page or search eBay sold prices for each one. Sell the valuable ones online if the price is much higher than a garage-sale price.
Price ordinary items simply
A common rule of thumb is a fraction of the new price for items in good shape, roughly a quarter to a third, and less for worn ones. It is only a starting point. Round prices make cash easier.
Use tiers
Clothes at one price, books at one price, kitchen items at one price. It saves time and buyers understand it.
Mark down on the last day
Everything that did not sell goes down, or into a "fill a bag" price. Anything left goes to donation.
Questions
How do I price items for a garage sale?
Check the few valuable items on sold prices, price the rest at simple round numbers well below the new price, and mark down on the last day.
Should I put prices on everything?
Yes. Buyers walk away from items with no price. Group tags on a table work well.
Related
Last updated 2026-10-17.